All Six Hunger Games Movies, Ranked (with Sunrise on the Reaping)
May the odds be ever in your favor.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping hits theaters this weekend! In celebration, I will be doing a few separate posts ranking this franchise. I adore The Hunger Games - I grew up with the books, and as soon as Suzanne Collins started releasing these prequels, I was fully on board. The movies have not disappointed so far. This is one of the most consistent film franchises out there. I like every single movie on this list (some more than others), so check out below to see where Sunrise on the Reaping lands. There are no spoilers for The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping in this post.
6. The Hunger Games: Mockingjay - Part 2
A decent but underwhelming finale to Katniss's journey

All in all, Mockingjay is a satisfying but heavily flawed conclusion to the story of The Hunger Games, and I think you feel that in this film. The film exchanges the tension and dread of Mockingjay - Part 1 for an all-out dystopian war story, and I think that hurts the movie a bit. The pace feels very wonky. It'll go from a long, epic action sequence to characters talking in sewers. The action, while great, doesn't always feel like it services the narrative. This movie gets so far away from what the other three films were that it's hard not to feel like you are watching a different franchise.
I do still like this movie, though, and I think a lot of that is due to the unflinching brutality of it's ending. Nobody really wins in Mockingjay. Snow is defeated, sure, but Coin is either equally evil or worse. The whole reason this rebellion started was because Katniss wanted to protect Prim, so her dying in the line of fire is an absolutely heart-breaking final beat of irony for The Hunger Games to end on. Katniss's final decision to go with Peeta and choose hope over anger is such a beautiful and bittersweet note for this series to end on, so for that, Mockingjay - Part 2 gets props. It isn't a perfect movie by any means, but it does a good job of wrapping up the characters and the story.
5. The Hunger Games
A grim adaptation of Suzanne Collins's iconic dystopian world

I am not a huge fan of the original film. Again, I like all of these movies including this one, but most people have it in their top two, and I've never quite been there. What works so well is its iron grip of the political commentary and the commitment to the concept of the story. The Hunger Games is a horrifying, dark, and unabashedly cruel idea, and this movie leans into that. We see the anger and trauma of the tributes. We see how broken characters like Haymitch are. We see Katniss's reluctance and fierceness on full display as she tries to navigate the shock of being thrust into the Games. And we see the control of the Capitol begin to slip away as Katniss and Peeta's burgeoning romance begins to prove more powerful than their control.
This movie does adapt the book well, but I find it to be a pretty ugly movie to watch. Every other Hunger Games movies has a sleek elegance to it that feels like it juxtaposes super well with the grittiness of the story, but this film feels a bit cheaper and blander than those. Gary Ross directed it with the intention of realism, and, while I applaud the effort, I don't think that's the right tone for The Hunger Games. The whole point is that the mask of the Capitol is meant to be one of elegance and wealth while the true ugliness is beneath the surface in the way they dehumanize and oppress the districts. The shaky cam and spotty visuals just make this a really tough movie for me to connect with, which is a shame, because I do realize it's good. It's just never been one of my favorites.
4. The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping
Haymitch's origin might be the most emotional and tragic of the series

The newest Hunger Games film is really tied for second with the two above it, but I'm putting it at fourth for now. I think this is the best-looking film in the franchise. I think it could have the best cast and performances. I think it works beautifully as a prequel: it sets up the rebellion that is directly addressed in Catching Fire, and for that, I give it major props. Joseph Zada is a star in the making, because his transformation as Haymitch Abernathy is unbelievable. The themes about propaganda and controlling the narrative add such an interesting and complex layer to this film that I don't think any of the other films (besides my number one) have really captured that well. And, of course, this is the darkest and most emotional film in the franchise...kind of by a mile.
I also loved that we got to see the Capitol at the height of their power. Ralph Fiennes is terrifying as President Snow, mainly because he is at the apex of his control and understanding of the system in which he operates. This is the most evil and most cruel version of the character, and seeing how that affects Haymitch adds another layer of tragedy to the whole narrative. Where it falters is in its repetitiveness. This is the sixth Hunger Games movie, and the film follows the formula pretty soundly. The book does this too, but it just feels like there aren't many surprises or exciting new directions - it just adds an extra layer of tragedy and complexity to Haymitch, which, all in all, is still a good thing in the long run.
3. The Hunger Games: Mockingjay - Part 1
A thrilling expansion of the story outside of the arena

I was really debating between this and Sunrise in my third spot, but I don't think people give Mockingjay - Part 1 enough credit, so I threw it up here. This movie is a taut, emotional story from beginning to end. I feel very similarly about this film and Deathly Hallows - Part 1. They are hated on because they're slower and more focused on set up, but I think what both of these part ones do so well is they give us time with the characters before the final confrontation. We know Katniss is going to battle the Capitol and Snow (even though she actually kind of doesn't), so Mockingjay - Part 1 uses its runtime to make sure we care about her mission and understand all the major players in it.
What I love about this movie is how much it tests Katniss. Peeta, the person she relies on the most, is being used as the Capitol's weapon, and that really creates a good emotional tension that runs throughout the film. I love that the film slowly builds out Katniss as the reluctant Mockingjay. She's the symbol of hope and freedom across Panem, but she's also being manipulated by the people who run the cause she believes in. All of these moral questions build to a thrilling final sequence where Peeta is rescued and then revealed to have been brainwashed by the Capitol. Mockingjay - Part 1 is an imperfect movie, but it gives us time with the characters and delivers a very tense mix of dystopian war and political thriller, and for that, I think it deserves more appreciation than it gets.
2. The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes
President Snow's origin is tragic and deeply unsettling at the same time

I think Ballad is probably the most faithful adaptation of a Hunger Games book. Clocking in at nearly two hours and forty minutes, this movie essentially works as a character study of a young Coriolanus Snow. Tom Blyth delivers a charming yet menacing performance as the future president of Panem, and he is paired with Rachel Zegler's enigmatic Lucy Gray Baird. The complexity of their relationship and, by extension, Snow's relationship with the Hunger Games is what makes this movie so interesting. I love that Snow is still shown to be a terrible human being in this. He isn't some tragic, misunderstood anti-hero. Rather, the real tragedy comes from him making a series of terrible decisions that lead him down the path to becoming the monster that we know.
I also love seeing a primal version of Panem and the Hunger Games. This movie takes place years before the Hunger Games become the big spectacle that we've seen in the other films. It takes place in a stadium and the tributes are not treated with the glitz and glamor they'd received in the original films. They feel more brutal and less sanitized than what we've come to expect, and that just allows the movie to give us a different version of Panem than we're used to. I don't think it fully sticks the landing - Snow's final turn to evil does feel a bit rushed and I think Lucy Gray's disappearance is a little too ambiguous for me, but I still find this to be a very worthy and exciting prequel that expands on The Hunger Games beautifully.
1. The Hunger Games: Catching Fire
Political allegory and gorgeous sequences make this one of the best YA adaptations ever

I like the other five Hunger Games movies, but it's really going to be tough to top Catching Fire. This movie should be, in my opinion, talked about amongst the greatest sequels ever made. It expands on The Hunger Games in every aspect. The scale is bigger, the stakes are higher, the emotions are grander. It introduces us to a whole new batch of fantastic characters - Finnick, Beetee, Johanna, Plutarch, etc. Snow feels like an actual threat rather than the ominous being in the background. And you see the spark of rebellion catch fire (pun intended) and start to grow into something truly impactful.
This movie shines in its new, sleek look courtesy of Francis Lawrence. He threw away the gritty, grounded feel of the first film and gave us an epic, almost Shakespearean vibe to the world that fits Panem and the Games much better. Katniss and Peeta feel more well-rounded - the complexity of their romance and the love triangle with Gale is infinitely more compelling in Catching Fire than it is in The Hunger Games. The film is full of shocking twists about the arena and the true nature of the rebellion that keep you constantly on your toes. And, of course, the ending delivers a thrilling and ultimately shocking cliffhanger that leads perfectly into Mockingjay. I love it when it feels like movies or TV shows achieve their full potential, and I feel like Catching Fire is this series reaching its full potential and fulfilling the promise of the premise. I absolutely adore this film and I would be shocked if any movie ever dethrones it as number one.


Comments